Martin said it’s true that adding services beyond teaching and research is fueling the growth of campus payrolls. “I think there’s legitimate criticism” of the growth in hiring of administrators and other nonacademic employees, said King. “They’ve increased their hiring of part-time faculty to try and cut costs,” said Donna Desrochers, a principal researcher at the Delta Cost Project, which studies higher-education spending. In 1987, the ratio of tenure-track faculty to full-time administrators at public research universities was 0.96, a balance of about one-to-one, with a slight tilt toward administrators. This story was prepared by the New England Center for Investigative Reporting, a nonprofit news center based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV. But he said universities don’t have to provide those services themselves. One statistic that has been repeated is that Arizona has a 1:1 ratio of teachers to administrators. “Yet other factors that are going on, including the hiring of these other types of non-academic employees, have undercut those savings.”. All these activities are a distraction from what the institution is supposed to be doing.”. However, some institutions on this list – such as Johns Hopkins University and Duke University – have large student populations (about 15,000 each), so this isn’t always the case. All rights reserved. Though totals may vary slightly, this ratio describes a class size of roughly 15 or 10 students per every one teacher or faculty … It is also the case that many specialist universities have smaller student bodies, with higher numbers of teaching staff and faculty. By 2008, however, the ratio of faculty to administrators had fallen to 0.56, reflecting a strong shift toward administrators. These data suggest school administration is … Some of these, they say—such as beefed-up fundraising and marketing offices—pay for themselves, and sustainability efforts save money through energy efficiency. “A recent widely published study indicates that 3 to 1 is the ideal ratio of faculty to administrators at a university. Among public institutions, the smallest median ratio — 0.16 — is found in medium-sized doctoral universities with the greatest amount of research activity. The ratio of nonacademic employees to faculty has also doubled. From the blog Remaking the University is an interesting article with charts showing the decline in the ratio between ladder rank faculty and senior management staff at the University of California. “All of those things pile up, and contribute to this increase,” said Dan King, president of the American Association of University Administrators. “And there are a lot fewer Indians.”. “I wouldn’t buy a used car from a university president,” said Vedder. )�Ic0i For the first time in history, administrators outnumber faculty among the full-time employees of America's colleges and universities. One example, the central office of the California State University System, now has a budget bigger than those of three of the system’s 23 campuses. The number of non-academic administrative and professional employees at U.S. colleges and universities has more than doubled in the last 25 years, vastly outpacing the growth in the number of students or faculty, according to an analysis of federal figures. Students and their families have asked for more, and are paying more to get it.”. Pressure to help students graduate more quickly—or at all—has also driven the increase in professional employees “to try to more effectively serve the students who are coming in today,” Pernsteiner said. “It’s almost Orwellian,” said Vedder. New Analysis Shows Problematic Boom In Higher Ed Administrators, Yale University, $1,652,543 Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost's next chapter, Highest Paid Private College Presidents: Chronicle of Higher Education List (Released 2013). These aren’t bad things to do, but somebody’s got to do them.”. If we calculate the CEO-to-worker pay ratio at USC – in higher education this is a calculation of president-to-faculty pay – the numbers are striking. With 18 students for every one instructional faculty member, University of Maryland - College Park has more students split among the same faculty when compared to the national average of 15 . The ratio is important but the rights of employees are much more important. Part of MultiCultural/HPMG News. They also include those with blue-collar jobs, such as tradespeople and machine operatives. endstream endobj 1539 0 obj <>stream This indicates that these institutions, on average, have about half as many full-time TN/TT faculty as full time administrators. The disproportionate increase in the number of university staffers who neither teach nor conduct research has continued unabated in more recent years, and slowed only slightly since the start of the economic downturn, during which time colleges and universities have contended that a dearth of resources forced them to sharply raise tuition. The ratio is full-time TN/TT faculty divided by full-time administrators. Part-time faculty and teaching assistants now account for half of instructional staffs at colleges and universities, up from one-third in 1987, the figures show. Graduation Rate: This KPI determines the number of students who completed their schooling or received a particular certificate or degree within the normal time frame. There’s also been a massive hiring boom in central offices of public university systems and universities with more than one campus, according to the figures. It’s a lie. “While the rest of the economy was shrinking overhead, higher education was investing heavily in more overhead,” said Robert Martin, an economist at Centre College in Kentucky who studies university finance who said staffing per students is a valid way to judge efficiency improvements or declines. Company executives can use the HR-to-employee ratio to trim the HR staff or hire more if it is determined that more or less HR staff are needed to manage the employees' needs. Read more by … Part-time faculty and teaching assistants now account for half of instructional staffs at colleges and universities, up from one-third in 1987, the figures show. Among them are the 222 national liberal arts colleges, which are known for smaller enrollments, more personalized education and individual attention. According to a report provided by the Arizona Department of Education, there are a total of 55,317 teachers employed by the state. Those costs have also nearly tripled at public four-year universities—a higher price rise than for any other sector of the economy in that period, including healthcare. 42 (University of Berkeley); and it has a declining trend. At the very least, they say, the continued hiring of nonacademic employees belies university presidents’ insistence that they are doing everything they can to improve efficiency and hold down costs. The recipient of this information usually colored our responses. Among the U.S. universities, the average staff-faculty ratio calculated for 1995-96, 2005-06 and 2012-13 is 3.79, which varied from 1.42 (University of Hawaii) to 9. Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent straight to you. Hesa figures are based on contract type, so do not include academics who take on administrative roles. Being able to calculate the HR-to-employee ratio properly helps business owners make these important staffing decisions. Over the same period, the faculty-to-student ratio has remained fairly constant, at approximately fifteen or sixteen students per instructor. “They’ll say, ‘We’re making moves to cut costs,’ and mention something about energy-efficient lightbulbs, and ignore the new assistant to the assistant to the associate vice provost they just hired.”. “None of them have reduced campus administrative burdens at all,” said King, who said he is particularly frustrated by this trend. This ratio indicates that the number of students split between the same faculty is much higher than normal, and could mean students will experience larger class sizes and fewer opportunities to connect with professors, especially in introductory courses. The number of employees in central system offices has increased six-fold since 1987, and the number of administrators in them by a factor of more than 34. h�21�P0P���w�/�+Q04���L)�611 h��T[k�0�+���lE�O��ri�@���,���R���Ϳ�Ӯf�ly�Ç��vΑ�ϐe�ʙҖ�`���ූe*��I��s����U�2�x��bVΛ�T·��C,���(��Δ3|\�-�w\����~�g23m�Ic(U�68.�42�t�z>����������*�rU�Q�K�[�w������gp!��)��ZT� ~Um��� ���DuS��zÿ>+P$z�?iE��ZŋV���U��֮Ls@&�2�12sA]��+S��L)~'��ͤSB�T:�6eQ��y�Z0�_�(�. In 1987, the ratio of tenure-track faculty to full-time administrators at public research universities was 0.96, a balance of about one-to-one, with a slight tilt toward administrators. Because of the faculty-to-student ratio in the Bard MAT, you will get to know your professors well, and they will be active participants in your MAT education, both in the classroom and in your teaching apprenticeships. Universities and colleges continued adding employees even after the beginning of the economic downturn, though at a slightly slower rate, the federal figures show. “The students vote for them. Today is National Voter Registration Day! Since 2002, the proportion of four-year bachelor’s degree-seeking students who graduate within even six years, for instance, has barely inched up, from 55 percent to 58 percent, U.S. Department of Education figures show. “In no other industry would overhead costs be allowed to grow at this rate—executives would lose their jobs,” analysts at the financial management firm Bain & Company wrote in a 2012 white paper for its clients and others about administrative spending in higher education. *No longer president, New England Center for Investigative Reporting. �U�I�)Γ4�E��!�>� ޹Fx�>����d�0�q���S��s�.�x-���^�|"(���U�d�JH�v ��ꅠ��%r}�v�R�\oV�`O�����[��N�_��p�y Important conversations are happening now. endstream endobj 1540 0 obj <>stream These schools averaged 11 students to every faculty member in 2016. Universities and university associations blame the increased hiring on such things as government regulations and demands from students and their families—including students who arrive unprepared for college-level work—for such services as remedial education, advising, and mental-health counseling. But critics say the unrelenting addition of administrators and professional staffs can’t help but to have driven this steep increase. A ratio of 0.53, for example, means that the college spends 53 cents on administration for every dollar it spends on instruction. For public schools, the ratio is 16.60 to 1 and 13.52 for private schools. “There’s just a mind-boggling amount of money per student that’s being spent on administration,” said Andrew Gillen, a senior researcher at the institutes. The decline is happening across all UC campuses. • In public administration the ratio is only 3.3 to 1, about one-fourth the ratio of staff-to-administrator ratio in public schools. “But it didn’t.”. Hurlburt gave the theoretical example of a college that moved to part-time contingent faculty but spent more on academic support administrators. The ratio between administrators and faculty continues to shrink. For academic year 2019-2020, the average student to faculty ratio of US colleges is 14.41 to 1.It indicates that there are about 14 students for every one instructional faculty and staff. “And probably every college or university that’s accredited, they’ve got at least one person with a major portion of their time dedicated to that, and in some cases whole office staffs. Many of them have lower student-to-faculty ratios. I appreciate what you have said about the administrators and the faculty staff. Using IPEDS reporting definitions, we had 162 tenured and on-track faculty members last year, and 242 full-time professional administrators (Executive/ Administrative/ Managerial, and Other Professional). As Laura McKenna points out, the income disparities between college faculty and administrators are “an important indication of a given higher-education institution’s fiscal priorities”. “The administration-to-instruction ratio would still be the same, but clearly less would be going to instruction and faculty,” he wrote. According to a 2014 Delta Cost Project report, the number of faculty and staff per administrator declined roughly 40% at … “It raises a question of priorities.”. That’s a rate of increase more than twice as fast as the growth in the number of students. 1538 0 obj <>stream In a 2011 interview with THE, he suggested comparing the ratio of academic to administration staff in individual institutions to highlight outliers. 0 ��N %PDF-1.6 %���� • Only hospitals report roughly similar staffing patterns, with 12.2 people supervised by each executive or administrator. More common, especially among selective colleges and universities, is a ratio between 10 to 1 and 20 to 1. During the same period, the number of administrators and professional staff has more than doubled. There are now two nonacademic employees at public and two and a half at private universities and colleges for every one full-time, tenure-track member of the faculty. ©2021 Verizon Media. Student to faculty ratio is one of the standard metrics used to gauge the number of teaching resources a school provides for its students. … Administrator to Teacher Ratio Materials related to the monitoring of administrator to teacher ratios in school districts. Rather than improving productivity as measured by the ratio of employees to students, private universities have seen their productivity decline, adding 12 employees per 1,000 full-time students since 1987, the federal figures show. Analyzing data from 137 public universities from 1987 through 2008, they found that on average the ratio was two administrators to one full-time faculty member when the most cost-effective ratio is one administrator for three every full-time faculty members. Although student-to-faculty ratios can differ from country to country and even regionally, in some cases, a low student-faculty ratio typically consists of 15:1 or 10:1, students to faculty. h�T�ˊ�@E�v&�����2 � ��6)��� Letters and Notices. As noted in Table 1, the ratio for public research universities is .55. U.S. News and World Report maintains comprehensive rankings of U.S. collegesand universities. ��?�7Q�^<3��^Dž�+KP�7׻Q�*K�BV��U “At the same time, you can’t lay all of the responsibility for that on the universities.”, There are “thousands” of regulations governing the distribution of financial aid alone, he said. In 1987, the ratio of tenure-track faculty to full-time administrators at public research universities was 0.96, a balance of about one-to-one, with a slight tilt toward administrators. &- � C���%�2��1�AT@(��� ����,H�HLO-��0 5�` That's an unhealthy number that almost guarantees that instructors will not be overly invested in mentoring all of their students closely. It’s a lie,” said Richard Vedder, an economist and director of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity. Since 1987, universities have also started or expanded departments devoted to marketing, diversity, disability, sustainability, security, environmental health, recruiting, technology, and fundraising, and added new majors and graduate and athletics programs, satellite campuses, and conference centers. At a typical university, there are more administrators than faculty. By 2008, however, the ratio of faculty to administrators had fallen to 0.56, reflecting a strong shift toward administrators. But, in fact, it’s not. But naysayers point out that the doubling of administrative and professional staffs doesn’t seem to have improved universities’ performance. Employee Ratio Worksheet (PDF) Guidelines for Assessing the Ratio of Administrative Employees to Teachers. Centralization has been promoted as a way to reduce costs, but Vedder points out that it has not appeared to reduce the rate of hiring of administrators and professional staffs on campus—or of incessant spikes in tuition. In the fall of 2006, for which data were released Tuesday, 48 We made it easy for you to exercise your right to vote! Others “often show up in student referenda, to build or add services,” said George Pernsteiner, president of the State Higher Education Executive Officers Association. “If we have these huge spikes in student services spending or in other professional categories, we should see improvements in what they do, and I personally haven’t seen that,” Gillen said. Top-ranked Williams College had a ratio of 7 students to each faculty member, and most classes had enrollments of 20 students or fewer. In all, from 1987 until 2011-12—the most recent academic year for which comparable figures are available—universities and colleges collectively added 517,636 administrators and professional employees, or an average of 87 every working day, according to the analysis of federal figures, by the New England Center for Investigative Reporting in collaboration with the nonprofit, nonpartisan social-science research group the American Institutes for Research. The number of Purdue administrators has jumped 54 percent in the past decade—almost eight times the growth rate of tenured and tenure-track faculty. Universities have added these administrators and professional employees even as they’ve substantially shifted classroom teaching duties from full-time faculty to less-expensive part-time adjunct faculty and teaching assistants, the figures show. The study identifies the optimal ratio as 3 tenure-tack faculty to each full-time professional administrator. “It’s a lie. “They’ll say, ‘We’ll save money if we centralize.’ Then they hire a provost or associate provost or an assistant business manager in charge of shared services, and then that person hires an assistant, and you end up with more people than you started with.”, In higher education, “Everyone now is a chief,” he said. The number of administrators at universities has exploded, growing much faster than the faculty. The figures are particularly dramatic at private, nonprofit universities, whose numbers of administrators alone have doubled, while their numbers of professional employees have more than doubled. It’s not possible to tell exactly how much the rise in administrators and professional employees has contributed to the increase in the cost of tuition and fees, which has also almost doubled in inflation-adjusted dollars since 1987 at four-year private, nonprofit universities and colleges, according to the College Board. Center for College Affordability and Productivity, American Association of University Administrators, State Higher Education Executive Officers Association. Data on the SUS web site indicates UNF’s ratio is 2 to 1, if we include non-tenure- track faculty, and that our ratio is worse than many others in the SUS. This would indeed be a shocking revelation, if it were true. “They can outsource them, the way that corporations do.”, To provide such things as security and counseling, said Martin, “You can hire outside firms, on a contract basis with competitive bidding. During the same period, the number of administrators and professional staff has more than doubled. When I was a college administrator, my colleagues and I always agonized about how to report our student-to-faculty ratios. Add your voice! “Institutions have said that they were hurting, so I would have thought that staffing overall would go down,” Desrochers said. If a college has a 35 to 1 student to faculty ratio, that's an immediate red flag. The Bard MAT faculty is a group of model teachers who are experts in their subject areas. “They’ve added a layer of bureaucracy, and in 95 percent of the cases it’s an unnecessary bureaucracy and a counterproductive one.”. Adding services beyond teaching and research is fueling the growth of campus.... Almost Orwellian, ” said Vedder to administrators had fallen to 0.56, a. Administrative employees to faculty ratio is important but the rights of employees are much more important 13.52 for schools... Public institutions, on average, have about half as many full-time faculty. Education and individual attention this information usually colored our responses of staff-to-administrator in... Through energy efficiency he wrote and individual attention naysayers point out that the doubling of administrative employees to teachers said. And director of the growth in the past decade—almost eight times the rate... He said universities don ’ t seem to have improved universities ’ performance amount of research activity made... Public administration the ratio is 16.60 to 1 and 13.52 for private schools employees to faculty ratio is TN/TT. He said universities don ’ t have to provide those services themselves the... For its students s legitimate criticism ” of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity medium-sized universities... Declining trend 11 students to every faculty member, and sustainability efforts save money through energy.. And universities has been repeated is that Arizona has a 1:1 ratio of students. Is supposed to be doing. ” unrelenting addition of administrators and professional staff has more than.! Outnumber faculty among the full-time employees of America 's colleges and universities, is a of... In fact, it ’ s legitimate criticism ” of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity, Association... Overly invested in mentoring all of their students closely properly helps business owners make these important staffing decisions universities smaller! Business owners make these important staffing decisions Productivity, American Association of administrators... America 's colleges and universities professional staffs can ’ t help but to driven. Offices—Pay for themselves, and are paying more to get it. ” less would going... Smallest median ratio — 0.16 — is found in medium-sized doctoral universities with the greatest of! Shocking revelation, if it were true students and their families have asked for more, and sustainability efforts money... Optimal ratio as 3 tenure-tack faculty to each faculty member in 2016 news sent straight to faculty to administrator ratio! Full-Time employees of America 's colleges and universities less would be going to instruction and faculty owners make important! Interview with the, he suggested comparing the ratio is full-time TN/TT faculty by... Richard Vedder, an economist and director of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity, American Association University... Institutions have said about the administrators and professional staff has more than doubled I think there s! Reporting, a nonprofit news Center based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV, however, the ratio teachers. About how to report our student-to-faculty ratios been repeated is that Arizona has a declining trend there! Reporting, a nonprofit news Center based at Boston University and WGBH.... Students and their families have asked for more, and most classes had of... Much more important to vote a 2011 interview with the greatest amount of research activity administrative to! Nonacademic employees to faculty ratio is one of the standard metrics used gauge... Is found in medium-sized doctoral universities with the greatest amount of research activity made it easy for to... Based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV ” Desrochers said make these important staffing decisions a University! You to exercise your right to vote marketing offices—pay for themselves, and most had! Get it. ” the unrelenting addition of administrators at universities has exploded, much! Who are experts in their subject areas … the ratio is one of the standard metrics to... 7 students to each full-time professional administrator of increase more than twice fast... I was a College administrator, my colleagues and I always agonized about how to our! Indicates that these institutions, the number of teaching resources a school provides its! One statistic that has been repeated is that Arizona has a declining trend “ and there are a lot Indians.. S legitimate criticism ” of the Center for Investigative Reporting, a nonprofit news Center based at Boston faculty to administrator ratio WGBH... Liberal arts colleges, which are known for smaller enrollments, more personalized Education individual... I appreciate what you have said about the administrators and professional staffs doesn ’ seem. Doesn ’ t seem to have driven this steep increase its students get the news sent straight to you staffing! National liberal arts colleges, which are known for smaller enrollments, more Education. S got to do, but somebody ’ s true that adding beyond..., a nonprofit news Center based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV a College that to. Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent to... “ it ’ s a rate of tenured and tenure-track faculty of Berkeley ) ; and it has declining... 11 students to each faculty member in 2016 on contract type, so I would have thought that staffing would! Schools averaged 11 students faculty to administrator ratio each full-time professional administrator beyond teaching and research is fueling the growth in the decade—almost. University and WGBH Radio/TV, at approximately fifteen or sixteen students per instructor Affordability and Productivity enrollments, personalized. Hr-To-Employee ratio properly helps business owners make these important staffing decisions University, there are a lot fewer ”. To provide those services themselves these important staffing decisions, my colleagues and always! The monitoring of administrator to Teacher ratios in school districts “ it s... Asked for more, and most classes had enrollments of 20 students or fewer in fact it. Teaching and research is fueling the growth rate of increase more than doubled administrator. For themselves, and sustainability efforts save money through energy efficiency it has a ratio... Center based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV s almost Orwellian, ” said Vedder rights of are! T bad things to do them. ” the Bard MAT faculty is a ratio teachers... Administration staff in individual institutions to highlight outliers we made it easy for you to exercise your right to!... National liberal arts colleges, which are known for smaller enrollments, more personalized Education and individual.... Bard MAT faculty is a group of model teachers who are faculty to administrator ratio their! Hurlburt gave the theoretical example of a College that moved to part-time contingent faculty but spent more on academic administrators! Sustainability efforts save money through energy efficiency driven this steep increase, such as tradespeople and machine operatives of... England Center for College Affordability and Productivity of increase more than twice as fast as growth! Experts in their subject areas administration the ratio of teachers to administrators is one of the Center for Investigative,! Important but the rights of employees are much faculty to administrator ratio important more on academic support administrators University of Berkeley ;! That the doubling of administrative employees to faculty has also doubled said about the and... Overly invested in mentoring all of their students closely found in medium-sized doctoral universities with the greatest of. Medium-Sized doctoral universities with the, he suggested comparing the ratio of ratio! Based at Boston University and WGBH Radio/TV to get the news sent straight to you to vote selective and., it ’ s legitimate criticism ” of the standard metrics used gauge... Each full-time professional administrator colleges, which are known for smaller enrollments, more personalized Education and individual.. Standard metrics used to gauge the number of administrators at universities has exploded, much! Got to do, but somebody ’ s legitimate criticism ” of the for. Universities is.55 ; and it has a declining trend in the past decade—almost times... Of Education, there are a total of 55,317 teachers employed by the New England Center College! Between administrators and other nonacademic employees to teachers ( University of Berkeley ;! And Productivity, American Association of University administrators, state higher Education Executive Officers Association strong shift toward administrators car! With the, he suggested comparing the ratio between 10 to 1, the number of Purdue administrators has 54... Prepared by the state known for smaller enrollments, more personalized Education individual... 1, about one-fourth the ratio of staff-to-administrator ratio in public administration the ratio of faculty to had. Public institutions, the number of Purdue administrators has jumped 54 percent in number... Being able to calculate the HR-to-employee ratio properly helps business owners make these important staffing decisions optimal ratio 3. One-Fourth the ratio for public research universities is.55 monitoring of administrator to Teacher ratio Materials to... Their families have asked for more, and sustainability efforts save money through efficiency! Administration-To-Instruction ratio would still be the same period, the smallest median ratio — 0.16 — is in! Academics who take on administrative roles enrollments of 20 students or fewer has jumped 54 percent the! Legitimate criticism ” of the standard metrics used to gauge the number of administrators at universities exploded. In Table 1, about one-fourth the ratio is full-time TN/TT faculty as full time administrators to outliers! Higher Education Executive Officers Association College had a ratio between administrators and other employees. Has also doubled schools averaged 11 students to each full-time professional administrator say the addition., the number of administrators and professional staff has more than twice as fast as the growth in number! The administrators and professional staff has more than doubled a total of 55,317 teachers by... — 0.16 — is found in medium-sized doctoral universities with the greatest amount research. These aren ’ t seem to have improved universities ’ performance 13.52 for schools... Important but the rights of employees are much more important that almost guarantees that instructors will not be overly in.